Whataboutery

Part of speech: noun

Pronunciation: /wɒtəˈbaʊtəɹi/

Definitions

1. An argument technique that deflects criticism by raising a different issue is known as a tactic to divert attention away from the original topic
2. This strategy involves responding to an accusation with a counter-accusation or unrelated point to change the focus of the discussion
3. Employed in debates, this method shifts the conversation by highlighting another subject, often as an avoidance of actually addressing the initial claim

Etymology: The term "whataboutery" has a distinctly modern flavor, emerging as a colloquialism in the late 20th century to describe a particular rhetorical tactic. It refers to the practice of responding to an accusation or a difficult question by making a counter-accusation or raising a different issue, essentially redirecting the conversation rather than addressing the original point. The word is often used in political discourse, where it can serve as a deflection mechanism, allowing one party to avoid accountability by pointing to the faults of another. This noun is derived from a combination of the phrase "what about," which is frequently employed in these evasive arguments, and the suffix "-ery," which denotes a state or condition. The construction playfully captures the essence of the tactic: it is not just about saying "what about" something else; it embodies a whole approach to debate that often hinders productive dialogue. The first recorded usage of "whataboutery" dates back to the 1980s in the context of the political landscape of the United Kingdom, particularly during discussions about the Troubles in Northern Ireland. The term gained traction as it reflected a growing frustration with the way political discussions often devolved into finger-pointing and deflection rather than meaningful engagement with the issues at hand. Its usage highlights a broader cultural critique of discourse that prioritizes scoring points over genuine understanding or resolution. While it is often associated with political rhetoric, "whataboutery" has also found its way into everyday discussions, illustrating how this tactic is not confined to any one arena but is a pervasive aspect of human communication. Interestingly, the word not only serves as a critique of a specific argumentative strategy but also reveals the complexities of public discourse in an age where information is abundant yet often contentious. Its playful construction and the unique phenomenon it captures make "whataboutery" an insightful addition to the lexicon of modern English, reflecting both the challenges and the peculiarities of contemporary dialogue.

Synonyms: deflection, diversion